Who Is Joe Rogan Part One

At a Glance

• Problematic views on trans children - “Yeah, this is one of them little gods that you have to work. Yeah.” The speaker shows a lack of understanding and sensitivity towards trans children, implying that their identity is something that needs to be ‘worked’ or ‘fixed’.

• Authority and hierarchy - “And if you’re going to believe that the adults have the authority, then you have to believe that hierarchy has some value.” The speaker highlights a conundrum in the conversation where the idea of authority and hierarchy is at odds with the notion of an oppressive patriarchy.

• The importance of logic and science - “Anything where you need a major science to consistently, yeah, right? Anything where you need medical science to consistently inject chemicals into your body, they’re going to alter your hormones irreversibly at a very young age.” The speaker emphasizes the need for evidence-based reasoning and scientific understanding in matters of human biology and identity.

• The social construct of gender - “If it’s all nonsense. Like, just be a girl. Anything where you need a major science to consistently” The speaker challenges the idea that gender is a social construct, highlighting the complexities and paradoxes that arise when trying to apply this concept in real-world situations.

What to Do

• Don’t Assume Authority’s Infallibility - This piece of advice encourages individuals to question authority and not assume they are always right, especially when it comes to complex issues like gender identity. It promotes critical thinking and skepticism towards received wisdom.

• Consider the Logic Behind a Decision - This advice reminds us to evaluate decisions based on logic and evidence, rather than blind adherence to a particular ideology or authority figure. It encourages us to think critically and consider multiple perspectives.

• Be Cautious of Social Constructs that Require Medical Intervention - This advice cautions against the use of medical science to alter one’s body in response to social constructs, such as gender identity. It suggests that we should be wary of using medical interventions to resolve social issues, especially when it comes to children.

• Question the Relationship Between Hormones and Identity - This piece of advice encourages us to question the relationship between hormones and identity, particularly in the context of gender identity. It prompts us to consider whether the use of hormones to alter one’s body is a natural or necessary response to a particular social construct.

• Encourage Children to Explore their Identities without Medical Intervention - This advice suggests that children should be allowed to explore their identities without the need for medical intervention, such as hormone therapy. It promotes a more nuanced and patient approach to understanding children’s development and identity formation.

What to Get

• 12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos by Jordan Peterson - Amazon ‍
• Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief by Jordan Peterson - Amazon - For delving deeper into topics covered in the podcast topic. ‍

Summary

In this podcast episode, the host explores some thought-provoking topics with his guests. One of the main conversations revolves around trans children and the idea that if they identify as a girl, it’s best to just let them be a girl without intervening with hormones or medical science. The guest points out that this approach is particularly odd if you believe that gender is a social construct, which many people do in today’s society. He asks why we need to alter their hormones irreversibly at a young age and questions the necessity of medical science in consistently injecting chemicals into their bodies.

The conversation then takes a deeper dive into the complexities of ideology and how it can affect our perspectives on various issues. The guest explains that if you start with the assumption that society is an oppressive patriarchy, then anything related to this topic becomes untouchable and subject to authority. This leads to contradictions when trying to assert that hierarchy has no value while also believing in authority.

Another interesting point raised by the host is about the logic behind not letting trans children be themselves without medical intervention. The guest counters with a straightforward question: if gender is a social construct, then what’s the purpose of hormones? He argues that this apparent contradiction suggests that some fundamental ideas need to be supported at all costs, even when they contradict each other.

This podcast episode also touches on the complexities of human identity and how our beliefs can lead us down rabbit holes. The conversation highlights how certain ideologies can become so central that any opposing view is twisted or bent in a way that seems unapproachable, much like being near a gravitational field.